• Investigating a “Coulomb’s torsion balance with modifications” in the collections of the Deutsches Museum, Munich

    By Elisabetta Rossi (PhD candidate, University of Milan), Daniel Liu (Postdoc, Ludwig Maximilian University Munich), Julien Gressot (Postdoc, University of Neuchâtel) and Jesse Garrison (PhD candidate, University College London).

    A SIS Grant supports this research. A longer piece on this subject will feature in a future SIS Bulletin.

    During the 2023 workshop on “Material Culture in the History of Physics” held at the Deutsches Museum in Munich, a mystery object from the museum’s historical collection, which had been previously kept in the Bavarian Academy of Sciences (Bayerische Akademie der Wissenschaften) since at least the 1850s, if not earlier, was presented. The museum catalogue describes DM 1182 as a “Coulomb torsion balance with Jelin’s modifications” [1]; however, the apparatus displays significant visual differences from the well-known device created by Charles-Augustin de Coulomb to study electrical forces. Our team, consisting of Elisabetta Rossi, Daniel Liu, Jesse Garrison, and Julien Gressot, aimed to deepen the understanding of this peculiar object by uncovering the instrument’s history, exploring its function, and investigating modifications made by Julius Conrad von Yelin, a 19th-century German physicist.

    Initial Encounter and Investigation

    When we first saw the instrument, it was initially concealed under a cloth. At first glance, it appeared ordinary and incomplete, and not very “aesthetical”. Upon further examination, we recognized its complexity and potential significance. DM 1182 (Fig. 1) consists of a slightly irregular hexagonal wooden base with a rectangular hole (and a small door to close it); a round platform with a circular depression – matching the diameter of the glass dome – characterized by remarkably signs of use; a vertical wooden dowel (easily spinning) with a horizontal attached needle; a (removable) flat-convex brass instrument fitting into a transparent tube and connecting to a metal wire ending with a (screwing) ball coming out from the inner part of the basement; two vertical wooden columns, each with a kind of double hook facing down with very tiny holes; a wooden rectangular bridge connecting the two columns with a central knob.

    Figure 1: DM 1182, Deutsches Museum, Munich. From left to right: main apparatus, glass dome, and some detachable components (Picture by Daniel Liu).

    Historical Context

    We approached the investigation through an object biography framework, examining the instrument’s material construction, historical context, and intended function. This methodology allowed us to go beyond simple description and consider how DM 1182 was used and how it fit into the broader history of early scientific experimentation in electrostatics.
    As already glimpsed, DM 1182 – which had been transferred to the Deutsches Museum in 1905, shortly before the museum opened to the public in 1906 – has been catalogued a Coulomb torsion balance with modifications.
    In the 1780s years, the French physicist Charles-Augustin de Coulomb (1736-1806) used a suspended wire and a rotating rod (with an angular scale to measure displacement) to experimentally determine the law of attraction and repulsion between two electrical charges [2]. On the one hand, with respect to his original torsion balance (Fig. 2), DM 1182 lacks key features such as the wire, a suspended dumbbell, a counterweight for the rotating needle and a measurement scale – which, however, may have been lost during the displacement of the instrument. On the other hand, it shares similarities, such as the glass enclosure which shield the components from air currents while performing an electrical experiment.

    Parallels and differences raise questions about the originality of the apparatus and whether (and which) parts were missing, modified or added later. The German physicist Julius Conrad Von Yelin (1771-1826), who, according to the catalogue, modified the apparatus, was a German physicist and mathematician involved in debates about electrical forces in the early 19th century. His name appears in the Bavarian Academy of Sciences’s 1850 catalog of the physical-mathematical collections for different instruments, one of which was used to investigate the repulsive forces of electricity by weight. [4]
    Von Yelin modified several scientific instruments for experimental use. Currently dealing with his writings and books from the 1810s and 1820s, we believe that he adapted an earlier and perhaps simplified version of DM 1182, possibly a typical Columb balance, specifically to study repulsive electrical forces. His modifications may have been substantial – possibly, they may have involved the presence of the flat-convex brass conductor which carries a brass ball underneath the base, and the latter could be charged by a glass rod with a brass ball holder passing through the open rectangular door (we also thought there might be an electrophorus in the base, but there is no physical wooden support, i.e. the base is open, and we ruled this out).
    In the early 1990s, Peter Heering replicated Coulomb’s experiment historically and discovered that, even with an instrument as delicate as Coulomb’s torsion balance, the precise measurements required to demonstrate the inverse quadratic relationship between charge and repulsive force were extraordinarily difficult, if not impossible [5-6]. DM 1182, with its relatively massive rotating dowel and the friction of its two mounting points, could not be sensitive enough for such a precise physical measurement.

    Goals of Further Research

    Figure 2: Coulomb’s torsion balance [3]. (Source: Wikimedia Commons https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Bcoulomb.png)

    At present, we have evidence to state that DM 1182 is likely a variation of Coulomb’s original design, adapted for similar electrostatic studies by Von Yelin. However, the apparatus’ complete precise role and functioning in experimentation (or perhaps demonstration) remains uncertain for now, and we are committed to deepening our understanding of all its subcomponents going through new archival material. The final goal is to develop (and publish) a comprehensive biography of DM 1182. By piecing together its history and function, we aim to position it within the broader context of early 19th-century scientific research into electrostatics, using it as a case-study to show how scientific instruments can provide valuable perspectives on the development of knowledge and experimentation through the centuries.


    References

    [1] “Coulomb ‘sche Drehwage aus sechseckigem Sockel mit Glasschutzhaube Durchmesser 29 cm Gesamthöhe 46 cm – Coulomb ‘sche Drehwage nach Jelins Abänderung”, Deutsches Museum – Sammlungsmanagement, Grunddaten-Ausfruck, Obj. Id: 598591, Inv.-Nr. 1182.


    [2] Charles Augustin Coulomb, 1784. “Recherches théoriques et expérimentales sur la force de torsion, et sur l’élasticité des fils de métal,” Mémoires de l’Academie Royale des Sciences de l’Institut de France, vol. 87: 229–269.

    [3] Charles Augustin Coulomb, 1785. “Premier mémoire sur l’électricité et le magnétisme. Construction et usage d’une balance électrique fondée sur la propriété qu’ont les fils de métal d’avoir une force de réaction de torsion proportionnelle à l’angle de torsion. Détermination expérimentale de la loi suivant laquelle les éléments du même genre d’électricité se repoussent mutuellement,” Mémoires de l’Academie Royale des Sciences de l’Institut de France, vol. 88: 569-577.

    [4] “LI.71. Eine Coloumb’sche Drehwage nach Yelin’s Abänderung um die abstoßenden Kräfte der Elektrizität durch Gewicht auszudrücken”, Ohm, Georg Simon 1850. Catalog der physikalisch-mathematischen Sammlung des Staates. Manuskript. Deutsches Museum Archiv (DMA) HS 1954-6.

    [5] Heering, Peter 1992. “The Replication of the Torsion Balance Experiment: The Inverse Square Law, and Its Refutation by Early 19th-Century German Physicists,” in Restaging Coulomb: Usages, Controverses et Réplications Autour de La Balance de Torsion, ed. Christine Blondel and Matthias Dörries, Biblioteca Di Nuncius 15 (Firenze: L.S. Olschki, 1994), 47–66.

    [6] Heering, Peter 1992. “On Coulomb’s Inverse Square Law,” American Journal of Physics 60, no. 11: 988–94, doi:10.1119/1.17002.



  • Delineating the journey of European astronomical instruments in Ottoman education and beyond (1773-1923)

    By Solmaz Ceren Özdemir, graduate of the Masters programme in the History of Science Department at Istanbul University, Istanbul.

    A SIS Grant supports this research. A longer piece on this subject will feature in a future SIS Bulletin.

    History-telling through astronomical instruments enables us to follow clues about cross-cultural exchange from different aspects. From this view, our preliminary analysis of Ottoman astronomical literature uncovers clear evidence of significant scientific engagements in astronomical instruments with countries such as England, France, and Germany from 1773 to 1923. Therefore, this research project holds immense importance as it aims to identify and trace the European influence on Ottoman education and beyond, focusing on both the tangible impact of astronomical instruments and the influence embedded in written texts. Additionally, it seeks to assess these instruments within the context of Ottoman science, considering basic astronomical and mathematical principles. For this purpose, the study focuses on determining the diversity of scientific instruments transferred, analysing their areas of use, and disseminating them in the Ottoman astronomy literature.

    Tracing scientific instruments in Ottoman sources

    In 2017, I started my studies and developed an interest in astronomical instruments after encountering a treatise suggested by Dr Gaye Danışan, a member of the Department of the History of Science at Istanbul University, for presentation at a congress.

    Figure 1: Yorgaki Petropulos, Risale-i Mukaddime-i Küre, Istanbul University Rare Books Library, TY 6549, AH 1266, 1b-2a (Istanbul Rare Books Library).

    The first treatise I began to study, titled Tercüme-i Küre-i Müşebbeke Aleti (the translation of the instrument of armillary sphere) or Küre-i Sema Aleti (‘Instrument of the celestial sphere’) [1], or Risale-i Mukaddime-i Küre (‘Treatise on the introduction to the celestial sphere’) [2], is kept in both the Istanbul University Rare Books Library and the Konya Koyunoğlu Museum. It was translated from French into Turkish by Aleko-zâde Yorgaki Petropulos (fl. 1872), who was a translator attached to the Sublime Porte and the Seraskier (commander-in-chief of the Ottoman army, under the Ministry of War), in 1266 Hijri (1849/50) for instruction in higher education institutions within the Ottoman Empire. Although these manuscripts do not contain images, the styles of the instruments can be traced since the author describes two types of celestial spheres in detail (see Figure 1) [3]. 

    The manuscript includes a description of the ringed spheres made according to the Ptolemaic and Copernican systems and information on the use of these spheres. After stating that the most well-known models for sky observation belong to Ptolemy and Copernicus, the section titled ‘Sphere by the Ptolemaic model’ was started after this general astronomical information. This section consists of the first chapter in which the structure of the sphere is explained and a total of 12 chapters in which information about the rings on the sphere is given one by one.

    When the copies in Koyunoğlu Museum and Istanbul University Rare Works Library are analysed comparatively, differences in the date information and dedication of the work stand out rather than the differences in the information given about both copies. The date of the work is given only in the Koyunoğlu Museum copy. On the last page of this copy, the date 1266 Hijri is noted, which corresponds to the years 1849/50 CE. On the other hand, there is no date in the copy of the Istanbul University Rare Works Library. However, there is the following information in that copy, which is not included in the Koyunoğlu Museum copy; in the preface, the author dedicates his work to the Seraskier (commander-in-chief of the Ottoman army) Mehmet Fuad Pasha (1815-69). Mehmet Fuad Pasha held very important positions in the Ottoman Empire in the fields of translation and book publishing.

    In the chapter titled ‘Sphere by the Copernican model’, Copernicus stated that it was revealed by observations that the Earth revolves on its axis daily for twenty-four hours and around the Sun in one year. Petropulos draws attention to the fact that the problems encountered during observation in the Ptolemaic model due to the Earth being at the centre were eliminated with the Copernican model.

    Considering also that Danışan points to similarities between the description of celestial spheres in the text and instruments in the Bibliothèque Nationale de France (BnF) collection, I believe that conducting a comparative study on the celestial spheres in the BnF collection can provide more insights into tracing celestial spheres in Ottoman literature. For this purpose, I would like to examine the BnF collection in France.

    Secondly, I became deeply interested in the role of demonstration of instruments for education in the Ottoman Empire. Therefore, I embarked on a search for similar works in Ottoman scientific literature. My exploration led me to discover a copy of Ali Allahyar’s Sema Aleti İzahnâmesi (Prospectus of the Celestial Instrument) in the Atatürk Library [4]. My interest in this work intensified during my master’s thesis, entitled Eclipse Calculations and Observation in Ottoman Astronomy (1800-1922). It was further fuelled by Gaye Danışan, my thesis supervisor, who highlighted the similarities between the eclipse indicators in Ali Allahyar’s work and the eclipse instruments found in the BnF collection (see Figure 2) [5]. During my study, Allahyar’s work will be compared with the astronomical instruments in the BnF collection as well as those in the collections of other museums.

    Figure 2: Ali Allahyar, Sema Aleti İzahnâmesi ([İstanbul]: [Maarif-i Umumiye Nezâreti Telif ve Tercüme Dairesi], 1334 R [1918], 52-53 (Atatürk Library, open access online).

    Interpreting history through scientific instruments

    Figure 3: Universal sundial, nineteenth century, The History of Science Collection of Istanbul Technical University (Image by the author).

    During the preliminary research for this study, I encountered numerous scientific and astronomical instruments dating from the eighteenth to the twentieth centuries across various collections in Türkiye. These collections include the History of Science Collections at the Kandilli Observatory and Earthquake Research Institute, as well as the History of Science Collections of Istanbul Technical University. One such instrument is the universal sundial found in the History of Science collection at Istanbul Technical University, designed for use in any geographic location. It is believed that this instrument was imported to the Ottoman Empire from abroad (see Figure 3).  Currently, detailed information regarding its origin and intended use —whether for educational or observational purposes— is lacking. Therefore, one of the aims of this research project trace its historical journey and shed light on its significance.

    Figure 4: Sundial, The Kandilli Observatory and Earthquake Research Institute, History of Science Collection (Image by the author).

    Another example comes from the History of Science Collection at the Kandilli Observatory and Earthquake Research Institute. A sundial, which tells time by igniting gunpowder placed in the cannon on it, was brought from France in the 19th century (see Figure 4 and Figure 5).

    The diversity of instruments and artifacts encountered in museums is exciting, yet many unanswered questions remain. When the study period is pre-analysed, it is observed that scientific information was transmitted to the Ottoman Empire through texts and scientific instruments from various places such as France, England and Germany. This transmission of knowledge occurred through various channels. For instance, treatises were translated to be used as educational materials in institutions, materials and treatises were brought back through visits to various parts of Europe, or materials and treatises were brought by travelers to the Ottoman Empire. This situation raises several questions: who were the users of scientific instruments brought from different traditions? Were these works exclusively for students, or were they also utilised by sailors, muwaqqits (timekeepers), and munajjims (astronomers) of the period? Were the translated works utilised in educational institutions? Did these works impact the production of scientific instruments in the Ottoman Empire? 

    Figure 5: Sundial, The Kandilli Observatory and Earthquake Research Institute, History of Science Collection (Image by the author).

    In this context, within the scope of the project, I aim to explore the structural features of these instruments and trace their historical journeys. 

    I hope to present a detailed and comprehensive analysis of the instruments and treatises in the aforementioned collections in a forthcoming article in the SIS-Bulletin.


    References

    [1] Yorgaki Petropulos, Küre-i Sema Aleti, Konya Koyunoğlu Museum, MS 11357, AH 1266, 29 folios.

    [2] Yorgaki Petropulos, Risale-i Mukaddime-i Küre, Istanbul University Rare Books Library, TY 6549, AH 1266, 29 folios.

    [3] Özdemir, Solmaz Ceren 2017: “Yorgaki Petropolos’un Batlamyus ve Kopernik Modellerine Göre Tasvir Ettiği Küre-i Müşebbeke Aleti”, Istanbul University, Department of the History of Science Student Congress, 5 May 2017.

    [4] Ali Allahyar, Sema Aleti İzahnâmesi ([İstanbul]: [Maarif-i Umumiye Nezâreti Telif ve Tercüme Dairesi], 1334 R [1918].

    [5] Danışan, Gaye 2020: A Scientific tour among the mathematical instruments in the collection of the Bibliothèque Nationale de France”, Osmanlı Bilimi Araştırmaları 21/2: 427-434.



  • Precarious innovation in Francoist Spain: biography of an orbigraph

    By Anxo Vidal Nogueira, University of Valencia, Spain

    This research was supported by a SIS Grant. A longer piece on this subject will feature in a future SIS Bulletin.

    Figure 1: The orbigraph with the original table on which it was used, as well as the paperweights and an original calculation sheet. A and B are as described in the text. Table length in the vertical axis: 125 cm. Source: image taken by the author.

    Object biographies are a well-established approach in studies of the material culture of science (Pantalony, 2011; Anderson, 2013; Lourenço and Gessner, 2014). They offer the opportunity to deepen our understanding of the complex and often unknown relationship between scientific practice, community and technology. In this post I will explain the first results of my ongoing project, which reconstructs the biography of an orbigraph, a mathematical instrument located in the astronomical observatory of the Universidade de Santiago de Compostela (Galicia, Spain).

    The orbigraph is a special kind of integraph (a mechanical analogue computing device for plotting the integral of a graphically defined function) which allows the determination of the orbit of a double start. Its configuration consists of two main arms in a cross arrangement, working one of them as a rail in which the other can slide (see Figure 1). The rest of the apparatus is a group of arms assembled in such a way that when the point A describes a curve, the B point responds with another curve related to the first one by this mathematical expression:

    𝜌2𝜃˙ = constant

    This is basically Kepler’s square law, when the curves are the time evolution of the relative distance ρ and angle θ of two astronomical bodies. In short, sketching one of the curves, the orbigraph draws the other fulfilling Kepler’s law.

    Figure 2. Press coverage of the observatory activities, with Vidal Abascal and the orbigraph as its protagonists. Published in Diario La Noche, February 10, 1959. Source: Galiciana, Biblioteca Dixital de Galicia (http://biblioteca.galiciana.gal).

    The orbigraph was designed by the Galician mathematician and astronomer Enrique Vidal Abascal (1908-1994) circa 1950. It is still unclear when did he start working on it. We know for sure that by the year 1952 the observatory started the administrative process to receive an extraordinary economic assignment for its construction. This search for budget support and the apparatus construction itself took a long time, starting in 1952 and finishing only in February 1955, when the actual object arrived at the observatory. The making of the instrument was offered to at least three different companies, two Spanish and one outside Spain. Both Spanish companies declined the offer, arguing a work overload or a lack of experience in the field. Finally, the Swiss company Coradi accepted the project for 17,000 Swiss francs.

    The orbigraph became arguably the most important technology at the Santiago observatory, perhaps even more than the telescopes themselves. This is not a surprise considering that the double-star study was the main task of the observatory and the orbigraph facilitated it in a very considerable manner. It was perfectly inscribed in the observatory’s scientific production, systematically used for around 25 years, although it is difficult to establish the last time it was used. In the observatory infrastructure, it was a fundamental element as shown in the plan of the 1961 observatory expansion project, in which it had its own dedicated office.

    The orbigraph, moreover, appears to have been a tool of social and scientific status for the observatory and for its designer, considering its presence in contemporary newspaper coverage. In a precarious context with limited scientific production and achievements, the orbigraph original design and, specially, its international construction could be considered a milestone. Vidal Abascal’s identification as the orbigraph creator lasted throughout his life, not only in the public arena but also within the academic community, being systematically mentioned in all the obituaries made after his death.

    The orbigraph’s life is immersed in a very complex background in which many elements played a role. I hope to investigate this case with more documented sources, which I have already located, in a second research trip to Galicia.

    References

    Pantalony, D. 2011: Biography of an Artifact: The Theratron Junior and Canada’s Atomic Age. Scientia Canadensis, 34(1), 51-63

    Anderson, K. 2013: Beyond the Glass Cabinet: The History of Scientific Instruments. Revista Electrónica de Fuentes y Archivos, 4(4), 34-46

    Lourenço, M. C. and Gessner, S. 2014: Documenting Collections: Cornerstones for more history of science in museums. Science & Education, 23(4), 727-745



  • The use of volvelles in alchemy

    By Zoe Screti

    This research was supported by an SIS Grant. A longer piece on this subject will feature in a future SIS Bulletin.

    Figure 1. The volvelle beneath the parchment lining of the end board of alchemical compendium Latin MS 65.

    The alchemist’s laboratory was often a space which housed numerous tools and instruments. The recipes of three early modern English alchemists, Thomas Potter (fl.1580s), Clement Draper (1550-1620), and Sir Thomas Browne (1605-1682) all, for instance, called for the use of a glass stillatory, crucibles, ingots, marble stones, vials, alembics, philosophers’ eggs, rotundas, circulatory vessels, and urinals amongst other things (British Library, 1842). References to these sorts of vessels, tools, and instruments are commonplace in alchemical treatises, but there is a notable silence in these sources about the paper tools that may also have assisted alchemical practices.

    Paper tools in the form of volvelles featured regularly in the libraries of alchemical practitioners, and their presence may suggest that alchemists actively used these tools within their practices. The most suggestive link between paper tools and alchemical practices comes from a fifteenth-century manuscript in Manchester’s John Rylands Library. Concealed beneath the parchment lining of the end board of Latin MS 65 – an alchemical compendium – is a volvelle (Figure 1) which allows the user to measure the movements of the moon, as well as certain planets. The location of this volvelle, hidden within a tome of alchemical knowledge, primarily suggests that its intended purpose was to support alchemical practices as it would have been within easy reach of the alchemist using the compendium. This link is further confirmed by the celestial bodies noted within the volvelle: Mercury (quicksilver), Saturn (lead), Jupiter (tin), and the Moon (silver), each representing a key metal in the alchemical process. Thus both the content of the volvelle and its placement are suggestive of its intended usage.

    Books containing volvelles featured in the libraries of numerous prominent alchemists, including John Dee (1527-1608) who owned a copy of Johannes Trithemius’ Polygraphie et vniverselle escriture cabalistique (Paris, 1561) which contained twelve volvelles for calculating celestial movements. Other alchemists, meanwhile, produced their own. Notably, Leonhard Thurneisser (1531-1596) published Des Menschen Cirkel un Lauff in 1575, which featured an elaborate volvelle with depictions of two female alchemists at work beneath the moving parts. Like Latin MS 65, the proximity of alchemy to this volvelle directly correlates paper tools with alchemical practices, suggesting a link between the two that has hitherto remained unnoticed.

    But why should alchemists have counted volvelles amongst their collections of scientific instruments? The answer is threefold. Firstly, astrological volvelles could inform alchemists as to when to conduct certain experiments so as to take advantage of planetary alignments. These alignments were believed to be important spiritually for the matter being transformed within the alchemical vessel, but more practically instructed alchemists as to the correct seasons in which to practice so as to avoid disruptive climatic interferences. Secondly, lunar volvelles could aid the measurement of time, offering in particular an insight into the lengths of nights and days, which may have been useful for alchemists determining when to tend to their work. Finally, pneumonic volvelles, such as Lullian wheels, could help to decode alchemical texts, revealing encrypted meanings, a process that was inherent to alchemical practice (Rampling, 2020). In their many varied forms, then, volvelles could offer alchemists crucial guidance on when to practice and how to understand their texts, making it perhaps unsurprising to see them featured in alchemical libraries.

    My research, supported by a SIS Research Grant, has explored the presence of paper tools in alchemical laboratories, making it possible to demonstrate that volvelles were a common feature of alchemical libraries and laboratories. From volvelles nestled into the very fabric of an alchemical compendium, to Lullian wheels decrypting encoded texts, these paper tools were both useful and informative, ensuring their place in alchemical study.

    References

    British Library (BL), Sloane MS 1842: ‘Alchemical receipts’, fols.28r-54r; Sloane MS 3580 A, ‘The process for making gold’, fols.184v-187r; Sloane MS 3687, ‘Alchemical processes’, fols.105r-110v; Sloane MS 3688, ‘receipts from homfrae evans sone in lawe’, ‘Questions and notes upon the worke of Henry Tyler’, ‘The coppie of another Booke which I had of Mrs Jane Constable’, fols.3r-30r.

    Jennifer Rampling, 2020: Reading Alchemically: Guides to “philosophical” practice in early modern England. BJHS Themes, pp. 57-74.



  • Restoring and testing a Pixii version of Coulomb’s Torsion Balance acquired by the University of Barcelona in 1848

    By Júlia Garcia

    This research was supported by a SIS Grant. A longer piece on this subject will feature in a future SIS Bulletin.

    Figure 1. Pixii’s electrostatic torsion balance after its restoration in the History of Electromagnetism Exhibition. Credit: Facultat de Física de la Universitat de Barcelona.

    In 1785 Charles-Augustin Coulomb read his first memoir on electricity and magnetism in the French Académie des Sciences, where he described a torsion balance he had invented, and which he used to obtain the law that would later bear his name. From that point forward the instrument’s presence became common in physics cabinets, even becoming mandatory in Spanish higher education institutions in the nineteenth century.

    The instrument we examined is a Pixii torsion balance, most probably acquired by the University of Barcelona in September 1848 (Figure 1). We restored it and researched its biography so that it would shed light onto the characteristics of scientific education in Spain, specifically in the University of Barcelona, during the second half of the nineteenth century. The instrument, due to its materials and design, fails to replicate Coulomb’s experiment faithfully but is partially successful at representing it in a didactic manner.

    To learn more about the material intricacies of Coulomb’s experiment, his experience is replicated as faithfully as possible, concluding that it is in no way trivial, as many physics manuals treat it. There has been active discussion during the past thirty years about the possibility that Coulomb may have reached the inverse-square relationship through theory rather than experimentation, because of how complicated it was – and still is – to replicate his experiment by operating an electrostatic torsion balance the way he described. Other considerations could explain the difference in results when seemingly following Coulomb’s instructions, both in the past and in the present. Back in the eighteenth century, the nature of electricity remained largely unknown, and could have contributed to misinterpretations of Coulomb’s memoir. Coulomb’s ample experience with wire and torsion experiments could have also been a major factor in helping him succeed where others failed.

    In the forthcoming article in the SIS Bulletin, we look at an instrument’s past, not only through archival research but also through the replication of its use, so that it may tell us as much as it can about the context in which it was created and manufactured.


Last 20 posts

Shopping Basket